Showing posts with label high speed rail. Show all posts
Showing posts with label high speed rail. Show all posts

03 March 2011

Ugh...Florida...rail...will it ever happen?

This whole high-speed rail debacle in my home state has just got me upset in all kinds of ways. Frankly, I'm pretty much over it by now, and I honestly think the funds would be much better used in the Pacific Northwest because the politicians in this region are thirsty and begging for projects like this that are a "respectful" use of tax dollars.

You can read up on all of the crazy waste of time and money thanks to our wonderful new governor. Two state senators tried to sue the governor for overstepping his power as governor, and the case was in court today, and must be finally decided by tomorrow and reported back to Secretary LaHood.

I did just read an article though about Governor Scott holding his opposition and claiming that Tri-Rail is the perfect example of a failed rail system for Florida. He states in an interview with CNN that "Tri-Rail shows the potential problems with investing in high-speed rail."

Alright. Mr. Scott,

  1. Tri-Rail is by NO MEANS high-speed rail, much less an even comparable example to compare the Tampa-Orlando line with. You should get that straight.
  2. Tri-Rail IS a pretty failed system, but that is not at all the South Florida Regional Transportation Authority's (the agency that operates the train) fault. The train is slow, it does not connect the downtown cores of South Florida cities, and there is a major lack of connecting public transit to and from the stations. It should have been built along the eastern rail line down there, and everyone knows that, but due to regulations and property acquisition, etc, that never happened.
  3. And finally, Mr. Scott, how can we drill this into your brain? Public transportation is not meant to make money! It's meant to be subsidized. In the case of Florida's high-speed rail, that subsidy will be coming explicitly from the Feds. How can we make it any clearer?
It requires investment! The economic benefits seen from the resulting industry trends, tourism, travel, etc are what makes this investment worthwhile! I read news stories everyday of new high-speed trains opening in Europe and Asia, and think to myself how sad it is that because of people like you, Mr. Scott, we will be stuck in this automobile centered society forever.

It's truly sad.

19 February 2011

High-speed [de]rail

These past few weeks have been abnormally busy for me, so I have never had time to sit and write a full post. But I'd like to talk a bit about the whole high-speed rail debate again, especially what is happening with Florida Governor Rick Scott's rejection of Federal funds for the Tampa-Orlando line.

This past weekend, I once again visited Portland with a friend who was in town, and I traveled via the Amtrak Cascades line from Eugene. I enjoy every moment on this line because it has its own unique features specific to the Pacific Northwest that add to the whole experience of the region. This short two-ish hour train ride between Portland and Eugene is fantastic!...until a tree falls RIGHT in front of the train. Long story short, the train sustained significant damage, and we were forced to chug all the way back to Portland at a top speed of 15 mph to catch the red eye train that had been held for over an hour for us. A pleasant two hour trip turned into a seven hour nightmare on the tracks.

Yep, this happened Monday evening on my return trip back to Eugene. Granted there is absolutely nothing Amtrak could have done to prevent this from happening, since it was ultimately caused by the storms that were passing through the area that night. However, all but maybe one or two times that I have made this short trip to Portland, there have been issues with delays and random problems causing the train to be extremely delayed and ultimately making passengers upset and discouraged from riding Amtrak again. And the Cascades line is supposed to be one of the faster, more reliable routes in the US, which are designed for high-speed use but are limited to only 79 mph max speed! I often regret not taking the Amtrak buses between stations, because at least they can reroute themselves if something happens, they are never delayed, and are much quicker.

Not even two full days after this seven hour nightmare train ride, I get the news that the new governor of my home state, Rick Scott, has finally decided to deny the Federal high-speed rail funds set aside for nation's first line between Tampa and Orlando. Even though, I had begun to see this coming since his election and inauguration, I was still appalled at the decision and his reasoning behind it. Many politicians, including fellow Republicans, were shocked as well.

I have blabbered on about why I feel high-speed rail is so important to the future of America, and I won't repeat myself, you can just read again for yourself. But as the passengers on the Amtrak train and I sat for seven hours Monday night, even breaking into the rationed food, I couldn't help but think to myself once again that if we had a comprehensive high-speed system like those in Europe and Asia, problems like this would be few and far between. The reasoning that we shouldn't pour more money into Amtrak because it is a poorly managed, failing system, to me, is bunk. It is not poorly run, in my opinion as a frequent rider, it's just there has not been sufficient upgrades and maintenance to make it a successful program since it's inception 40 years ago.

It is time to make significant investments in the future infrastructure of our country, and the way it seems right now, Florida will not be leader any longer. Rick Scott has made a poor decision and has already poured hundreds of millions down the drain in research and preparation for this project, not mention the potential job loss that his entire campaign was focused on. I guess California and the Midwest will see all the benefits, and Florida will will be left in the dust, once again.

Sometimes, things are expensive, but when future benefits are at stake that will far outweigh costs now, the smart move is to invest. Instead, this money will be spent on outdated highway and other projects of the past, further holding America back from properly sustaining itself in the future, economically and environmentally.
Let's just hope the rumors of Scott's Presidential bid are anything but true.

(Infographic courtesy of amberofthismoment.tumblr.com)

08 January 2011

In the Reader

If you're anything like me and completely nerd out over transit maps and their design, you'll enjoy this article at The City Fix about Symbolism in the Transit World: Helping You Find Your Way.

Upon moving out to Oregon, I knew that Portland was one of the most livable cities in the country. I did, however, wonder where the kids were. There aren't many, and apparently there are downsides to this in some ways. The Conservative Planner takes a look at how this is common in the top 5 livable cities in the US.

City Limits has a great story about how the Obama Administrations urban policy initiatives are really happening whether you realize it or not.

An interesting look at how planning has become faith-based by "Exorcising the Suburban Dream". I do not agree with very much of what the author suggests other than the "principles" he says are the bylaws of our generation of planners. He criticizes them, but I think they are wonderful! Ha
  • Thou shalt build upon thy dwelling a porch of such magnitude that it can serve as a gathering place.
  • Thou shalt construct a path of 2 cubits (approximately 4 feet) wide near thy porch for followers to meet and pray that a cul-de-sac shall not influence thy offspring.
  • A place for chariots shall be placed upon the buttocks of thy dwelling. Thy chariot must not be nearer to the dwelling than 4 cubits or thee will be smitten.
  • Thou shall plant a tree half a cubit from thy curb and in front of thy porch.
  • Create a place for gathering no farther than 600 cubits from thy dwelling.
  • Thy dwelling shall have Craftsman trim.
  • The path to heaven is taken by bicycle, light rail, or walking, not by powered chariot.
  • A congregant must dwell in extreme closeness to thy neighbor.
Meanwhile in Florida...

A new governor was sworn in Tuesday morning. Republican bazillionaire, Rick Scott, took the office after a $73 million campaign and a full on $3 million inauguration ceremony followed by a freezing of all new government regulation in order to "be more growth-friendly". This is stalling much needed legislation from being created to manage important environmental things like the St. Johns River water supply.

Also, at this point in the future of Florida's high-speed rail, the recommended approach is the fiscally conservative one. The plan is not perfect as I've said before, but it is meant to be a pilot for the nation, and is something.

26 December 2010

Come on Rick Scott. Don't do this.

The new Florida governor-elect, Rick Scott, is showing some additional signs that he will not carry through with the new Florida high-speed-rail line between Tampa and Orlando, following suit with other Republican governors from Ohio and Wisconsin, claiming that they don't want to take more Federal dollars that would cost taxpayers.

Ray LaHood, U.S. Secretary of Transportation, wrote an Op-Ed in the Orlando Sentinel this week, emphasizing that "High-speed-rail will be our generation's legacy". His comments, directed at Rick Scott, are exactly what I would have argued if I was put in his position. Scott's campaign platform was all about jobs, jobs, jobs. Some elaborate plan using the number '7' (that he had published) to create an extremely optimistic amount of jobs in his term. Jobs? Construction industry jobs? What Florida is really good at? And Scott is considering turning down a high-speed-rail project? How many thousands of jobs will he be missing out on? I wouldn't be too disappointed if he even claimed all of the jobs created by such a project as ones toward his goal!

Instead, he is still undecided, and rather mute, about the topic, and it is beginning to worry myself and others. This is such an incredible opportunity for the region and the country! Even though the proposed rail line has flaws, right now, it IS a pilot, and it IS SOMETHING! If nothing happens now, nothing will ever happen, and all of the money that has already been spent on planning for this project will go to waste, and all of the money set aside for construction, will most likely end up in California, where amazing plans for their line will become reality sooner rather than later.

Dear Rick Scott,
Don't be a like all of the other Republicans. You said you were a "political outsider", and people believed you (for some ridiculous reason). Live up to your promises.
Sincerely,
Landon

02 December 2010

The High-Speed Rail and Transit Debacle

Since President Obama has been in office, there has been a massive push from many parties to establish the groundwork for a high-speed rail system here in the United States. With the admirable leadership of Secretary of Transportation Ray LaHood, the funding has become available and already dispersed to construct several rail corridors as pilots for the rest of the country, one being in my homestate of Florida between Tampa and Orlando. Though this line and the others are far from perfect and only a baby step in establishing a nationwide system (which honestly, seems more and more like a farfetched dream), it is SOMETHING!

However, over the past few weeks leading up to the midterm elections and the weeks since, there has been a sudden backlash against these high-speed rail projects as well as other public transit projects within cities. This anti-transit sentiment seems to be due solely to the fact that tax dollars are required to fund these projects.

Well, DUHH!

Do these governors who actually want to give back federal dollars because they think this is a waste of taxpayer dollars really believe that things will just happen? Even with a market like this? Some solutions are to just not spend the money (even though thousands of jobs would be created...) or to put it toward something like highways. Really?

Transit is not meant to make money. It is meant to be equitable. It's purpose is to help people go from point A to point B quickly, efficiently, and sustainably. Is this something that private, deep pocketed investors can provide? Maybe. But the role of government, at least in the United States, according to the Preamble of our Constitution is to "form a more perfect Union,...insure domestic Tranquility,...promote the general Welfare..." I am pretty confident that providing decent public transit is an obligation of our government.

Now, this does not mean that we are off the hook, of course. Do we realize how much we drive and take the plane? Do we realize how dependent we have become on these things? Do we understand the impact it is having on our future? Do we know that there are alternatives, like effective transit and inter-city rail out there? Do we let our government know that we want those alternatives? Are we willing to pay a bit more in taxes? Why not?

I think our politicians and those who are afraid of taxes need to grow a pair and deal with it. Establish the proposed gas sales tax. Levy an income tax in places that don't have one (ahem...Florida...). There, I said it! Call me a socialist, but I will just refer to you as a greedy, non-communal, and blind to the fact that we're actually not the best country in the world like you continue to believe. (I probably won't do that, because I'm nice)

But really, America. I continue to be ashamed that this is even an issue.